altruism: be problem for theory

Related concepts

Parents	behavior Weight: 0.68 , virtue Weight: 0.65 , concept Weight: 0.62 , trait Weight: 0.60 , value Weight: 0.60
Siblings	compassion Weight: 0.36 , kindness Weight: 0.36 , patriotism Weight: 0.35 , greed Weight: 0.35 , generosity Weight: 0.35

Related properties

Property	Similarity
be problem for theory	1.00
be problem for evolutionary theory	0.90
be problem in society	0.82
be explainable according to rational choice theory	0.80
be explainable according to choice theory	0.79
is bad thing	0.76
is thing	0.75

Priors about this statement

Cues

Evidence

Clauses

Plausibility inference from child typicality

0.22

Rule weight: 0.66
Evidence weight: 0.42
Similarity weight: 0.79

Evidence: 0.19

Plausible(behavior, be explainable according to choice theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.72

¬ Typical(altruism, be problem for theory)

0.19

Rule weight: 0.66
Evidence weight: 0.36
Similarity weight: 0.80

Evidence: 0.10

Plausible(behavior, be explainable according to rational choice theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.72

¬ Typical(altruism, be problem for theory)

Plausibility inheritance from parent to child

0.07

Rule weight: 0.09
Evidence weight: 0.95
Similarity weight: 0.80

Evidence: 0.53

Plausible(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.10

¬ Plausible(behavior, be explainable according to rational choice theory)

0.07

Rule weight: 0.09
Evidence weight: 0.91
Similarity weight: 0.79

Evidence: 0.53

Plausible(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.19

¬ Plausible(behavior, be explainable according to choice theory)

Remarkability exclusitivity betweem a parent and a child

0.44

Rule weight: 0.58
Evidence weight: 0.97
Similarity weight: 0.80

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.10

¬ Remarkable(behavior, be explainable according to rational choice theory)

0.44

Rule weight: 0.58
Evidence weight: 0.96
Similarity weight: 0.79

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.13

¬ Remarkable(behavior, be explainable according to choice theory)

Remarkability exclusitivity between siblings

0.10

Rule weight: 0.13
Evidence weight: 0.90
Similarity weight: 0.82

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.32

¬ Remarkable(greed, be problem in society)

0.10

Rule weight: 0.13
Evidence weight: 0.95
Similarity weight: 0.76

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.18

¬ Remarkable(compassion, is bad thing)

0.09

Rule weight: 0.13
Evidence weight: 0.92
Similarity weight: 0.76

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.28

¬ Remarkable(patriotism, is bad thing)

0.07

Rule weight: 0.13
Evidence weight: 0.70
Similarity weight: 0.76

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.98

¬ Remarkable(greed, is bad thing)

0.07

Rule weight: 0.13
Evidence weight: 0.70
Similarity weight: 0.75

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.98

¬ Remarkable(patriotism, is thing)

0.07

Rule weight: 0.13
Evidence weight: 0.70
Similarity weight: 0.75

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.99

¬ Remarkable(compassion, is thing)

0.07

Rule weight: 0.13
Evidence weight: 0.70
Similarity weight: 0.75

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.99

¬ Remarkable(greed, is thing)

Remarkability from parent implausibility

0.23

Rule weight: 0.42
Evidence weight: 0.70
Similarity weight: 0.79

Evidence: 0.19

Plausible(behavior, be explainable according to choice theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.31

Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.53

¬ Plausible(altruism, be problem for theory)

0.23

Rule weight: 0.42
Evidence weight: 0.67
Similarity weight: 0.80

Evidence: 0.10

Plausible(behavior, be explainable according to rational choice theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.31

Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.53

¬ Plausible(altruism, be problem for theory)

Remarkability from sibling implausibility

0.45

Rule weight: 0.60
Evidence weight: 1.00
Similarity weight: 0.76

Evidence: 0.53

Plausible(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.98

Remarkable(greed, is bad thing) ⋁

Evidence: 0.17

¬ Plausible(greed, is bad thing)

0.45

Rule weight: 0.60
Evidence weight: 1.00
Similarity weight: 0.75

Evidence: 0.53

Plausible(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.99

Remarkable(greed, is thing) ⋁

Evidence: 0.15

¬ Plausible(greed, is thing)

0.45

Rule weight: 0.60
Evidence weight: 1.00
Similarity weight: 0.75

Evidence: 0.53

Plausible(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.99

Remarkable(compassion, is thing) ⋁

Evidence: 0.18

¬ Plausible(compassion, is thing)

0.45

Rule weight: 0.60
Evidence weight: 1.00
Similarity weight: 0.75

Evidence: 0.53

Plausible(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.98

Remarkable(patriotism, is thing) ⋁

Evidence: 0.24

¬ Plausible(patriotism, is thing)

0.44

Rule weight: 0.60
Evidence weight: 0.98
Similarity weight: 0.76

Evidence: 0.53

Plausible(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.18

Remarkable(compassion, is bad thing) ⋁

Evidence: 0.06

¬ Plausible(compassion, is bad thing)

0.44

Rule weight: 0.60
Evidence weight: 0.89
Similarity weight: 0.82

Evidence: 0.53

Plausible(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.32

Remarkable(greed, be problem in society) ⋁

Evidence: 0.34

¬ Plausible(greed, be problem in society)

0.44

Rule weight: 0.60
Evidence weight: 0.96
Similarity weight: 0.76

Evidence: 0.53

Plausible(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.28

Remarkable(patriotism, is bad thing) ⋁

Evidence: 0.12

¬ Plausible(patriotism, is bad thing)

Salient implies Plausible

0.23

Rule weight: 0.28
Evidence weight: 0.80
Similarity weight: 1.00

Evidence: 0.53

Plausible(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.42

¬ Salient(altruism, be problem for theory)

Similarity expansion

0.64

Rule weight: 0.85
Evidence weight: 1.00
Similarity weight: 0.75

Evidence: 0.72

Typical(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.02

¬ Typical(altruism, is thing)

0.62

Rule weight: 0.85
Evidence weight: 0.81
Similarity weight: 0.90

Evidence: 0.72

Typical(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.68

¬ Typical(altruism, be problem for evolutionary theory)

0.59

Rule weight: 0.85
Evidence weight: 0.91
Similarity weight: 0.75

Evidence: 0.53

Plausible(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.19

¬ Plausible(altruism, is thing)

0.57

Rule weight: 0.85
Evidence weight: 0.75
Similarity weight: 0.90

Evidence: 0.31

Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.36

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for evolutionary theory)

0.57

Rule weight: 0.85
Evidence weight: 0.74
Similarity weight: 0.90

Evidence: 0.53

Plausible(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.54

¬ Plausible(altruism, be problem for evolutionary theory)

0.56

Rule weight: 0.85
Evidence weight: 0.73
Similarity weight: 0.90

Evidence: 0.42

Salient(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.47

¬ Salient(altruism, be problem for evolutionary theory)

0.46

Rule weight: 0.85
Evidence weight: 0.71
Similarity weight: 0.75

Evidence: 0.42

Salient(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.50

¬ Salient(altruism, is thing)

0.20

Rule weight: 0.85
Evidence weight: 0.32
Similarity weight: 0.75

Evidence: 0.31

Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.99

¬ Remarkable(altruism, is thing)

Typical and Remarkable implies Salient

0.12

Rule weight: 0.14
Evidence weight: 0.87
Similarity weight: 1.00

Evidence: 0.42

Salient(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.72

¬ Typical(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory)

Typical implies Plausible

0.32

Rule weight: 0.48
Evidence weight: 0.66
Similarity weight: 1.00

Evidence: 0.53

Plausible(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.72

¬ Typical(altruism, be problem for theory)

Typicality and Rermarkability incompatibility between a parent and a child

0.36

Rule weight: 0.51
Evidence weight: 0.89
Similarity weight: 0.80

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.35

¬ Typical(behavior, be explainable according to rational choice theory)

0.35

Rule weight: 0.51
Evidence weight: 0.86
Similarity weight: 0.79

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.47

¬ Typical(behavior, be explainable according to choice theory)

Typicality and Rermarkability incompatibility between siblings

0.10

Rule weight: 0.14
Evidence weight: 0.99
Similarity weight: 0.76

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.02

¬ Typical(greed, is bad thing)

0.10

Rule weight: 0.14
Evidence weight: 1.00
Similarity weight: 0.75

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.00

¬ Typical(greed, is thing)

0.10

Rule weight: 0.14
Evidence weight: 1.00
Similarity weight: 0.75

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.01

¬ Typical(compassion, is thing)

0.10

Rule weight: 0.14
Evidence weight: 0.99
Similarity weight: 0.75

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.04

¬ Typical(patriotism, is thing)

0.10

Rule weight: 0.14
Evidence weight: 0.95
Similarity weight: 0.76

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.17

¬ Typical(compassion, is bad thing)

0.10

Rule weight: 0.14
Evidence weight: 0.93
Similarity weight: 0.76

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.24

¬ Typical(patriotism, is bad thing)

0.10

Rule weight: 0.14
Evidence weight: 0.85
Similarity weight: 0.82

Evidence: 0.31

¬ Remarkable(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.48

¬ Typical(greed, be problem in society)

Typicality inheritance from parent to child

0.35

Rule weight: 0.48
Evidence weight: 0.90
Similarity weight: 0.80

Evidence: 0.72

Typical(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.35

¬ Typical(behavior, be explainable according to rational choice theory)

0.33

Rule weight: 0.48
Evidence weight: 0.87
Similarity weight: 0.79

Evidence: 0.72

Typical(altruism, be problem for theory) ⋁

Evidence: 0.47

¬ Typical(behavior, be explainable according to choice theory)